NASA's selection process for the Artemis III crew has always been a bit of a mystery, with a recent meeting raising more questions than it answered. The event, which took place two weeks before the public announcement, was designed to bring all five astronauts together in the same room, but the criteria for their selection remain unclear. This is particularly intriguing given the complexity of the Artemis III mission and the tight training schedule. The crew, including three NASA astronauts and one from the European Space Agency, will have just 18 months to prepare, which is significantly less time than the Artemis II crew had for their mission to the Moon. This raises the question: what makes an astronaut suitable for the Artemis program? Is it purely based on merit, or are there other factors at play? The process is shrouded in secrecy, with even NASA management not revealing the reasons behind their choices. This lack of transparency is not new; the selection of the first American astronauts was also shrouded in mystery, with Alan Shepard learning of his assignment over the phone. The Artemis III crew's selection, however, seems to have been more personal, with NASA chief astronaut Scott Tingle telling them directly, 'Look around. This is your Artemis 3 crew.' This approach, while effective in building morale, leaves many questions unanswered. The selection process is a critical aspect of the Artemis program's success, and the lack of clarity around it could impact the program's overall credibility. NASA's management needs to be more transparent about the selection criteria and the reasons behind their choices. The public has a right to know how these astronauts were chosen, and the reasons behind their selection. Otherwise, the program risks being perceived as elitist and exclusive, which could undermine its support among the public. In my opinion, NASA should consider making the selection process more open and transparent. This would not only build trust with the public but also provide valuable insights into the criteria used to select astronauts. The selection process is a critical aspect of the Artemis program's success, and the lack of clarity around it could impact the program's overall credibility. NASA needs to be more open and transparent about the selection criteria and the reasons behind their choices. Only then can the public fully understand and support the program's goals and objectives.